EXPERT INSIGHTS | U.S. ARTICLE SERIES | PART 1 OF 5
Stable, but unpredictable?
Why the U.S. insurance market is redefining old rules.
After several years of tight market conditions, the US insurance market is showing signs of stabilisation. However, certain lines of business and regions still remain under duress. In the first part of our 5-part US series, we will display the liability risk exposure arising out of US tort case law. In addition, the US insurance market has changed due to more restricted UW guidelines during the past couple of years.
Status Quo and Trends within the US Insurance market
Low-risk segments continue to experience stable premiums, while catastrophe-prone areas and states with stricter legal frameworks see pressure intensify.
Even long-standing, claims-free policies are increasingly affected by non-renewals, signalling a sustainable shift in underwriting strategies.
Courts and Catastrophes: When Legal and Natural Forces Amplify Risk
A key driver of volatility is the rise of “nuclear verdicts”—jury awards exceeding USD 10 million—fueled by social inflation and broader legal and societal changes. As a consequence, we are confronted with more unpredictable jury verdicts and greater damages.
Plaintiff-friendly juries, scepticism towards large corporations, and emotionally charged litigation—particularly in states such as California, Washington, and Georgia—challenge traditional risk models. Liability lines such as General Liability, Excess/Umbrella, Auto Liability, and Professional Liability are most affected, as awards can reach existential levels.
Even without final judgments, litigation volumes generate substantial defence costs. One of the key functions of liability insurance is the insurer’s duty to defend policyholders—both financially and legally. The goal is to keep insureds out of litigation or remove them from it in the early stages of lawsuits. Defence costs directly influence premiums, deductibles, and insurance carriers’ underwriting appetite.
Natural catastrophe exposure in property insurance remains high, particularly along coastal regions. Hurricanes, tornadoes, wildfires, flooding, and severe hail events continue to produce major losses in commercial and industrial portfolios.
Insurers are responding by reassessing portfolios through higher pricing, targeted exclusions, or withdrawal from specific segments.
Note: An in depth analysis for NAT CAT risks will follow in part 3 of this series.
The Role of Reinsurance and Environmental, Social, Governance (ESG)
Reinsurers increasingly shape primary insurers’ underwriting strategies, promoting selective underwriting and stricter risk appetites. Rising natural catastrophe risks and ESG considerations are key drivers, especially in sectors such as Oil & Gas, Chemicals, Pharma, Technology, and Defence-related industries.
In the US, ESG is often applied discreetly through internal underwriting guidelines rather than explicit policy wording. Decisions may result in unexpected declinations for international clients, often without detailed explanation. Only in conversations between brokers and Underwriters those new restrictions surface. Another reason for restrictive Underwriting is the reduction in reinsurance capacity.
Practical Challenges for Policy Renewals
These market shifts create tangible challenges for renewals. Insurers respond with short-term adjustments, higher premiums, and occasional non-renewals, even for longstanding, claims-free policies.
It creates challenges for clients and brokers in meeting tight time lines to find replacements. Temporary coverage is typically limited to 30 days, increasing pressure to secure alternatives quickly. Premiums for coverage that replaces non-renewed policies are often higher priced.
International programme clients may face additional complications if offsetting coverage is unavailable.
Conclusion: Proactive Collaboration is Key
Brokers and policyholders must work early and proactively together to navigate these dynamic conditions:
- Develop flexible placement strategies
- Engage local expertise
- Begin negotiations early on
To find suitable coverage, those rules need to be followed. Negotiations with Insurance carriers typically begin approximately 90–120 days before the expiration date of the policies.
Clients and risk managers should facilitate a transparent, timely flow of information between the company, brokers, and insurers. Delays or incomplete risk information data reduce placement options and may force acceptance of less favourable terms.
High-quality data and risk information enable the broker to find adequate coverage solutions. The broker needs to work closely with the Underwriters and reinsurance markets. The broker also needs to be proactive.
Outlook
In Part 2 of this series, we will examine why smaller companies and start-ups increasingly struggle to secure adequate insurance solutions.


